We, the undersigned, applaud the intent of
Title IX and agree that athletic opportunity is important to both male and
female athletes.
We however, disagree with the interpretation of Title IX by the Department of
Education. The Education Department has created three ways for a school to avoid
discrimination under Title IX. These guidelines have never been approved by any
president as required by the procedures adopted by the executive branch of
government. The guidelines have been applied in a way that no school is likely
to satisfy them without meeting arbitrary quotas between male and female
participation in athletics, regardless of the actual interest level of male and
female students. The Department's aggressive enforcement of those quotas has not
resulted in significant gains for women, but has resulted primarily in the
destruction of opportunities for men. Presently for every female athlete added
to a college sports program under those guidelines, four or five male athletes
are being dropped. If the present trend continues, many sports programs for men
at the college level will soon be extinct. Since 1972, 433 college wrestling
programs have been eliminated as a result of this approach.
Quotas have been invalidated in all other areas of the law and should not be
allowed in the area of collegiate athletics. We believe that opportunities
should be created for women who want to participate in athletics, but equality
is not gained by prohibiting other people from participating just so that the
numbers look right. Arbitrary quotas do not take into account the individual
preferences and choices of both men and women. Women currently out number men at
most colleges and universities. Women's collegiate sports programs currently out
number men's programs. However, women still participate at a lower level of
participation than men. If more women do not want to participate in sports, men
should not be prohibited from participating just so that the numbers of
participants are the same. We do not limit women from participating in choir,
dance, drama and other activities in which women participants far out number
men, and we should not arbitrarily limit opportunities for men, especially with
no corresponding benefit for women.
We believe in the spirit of Title IX. We believe that no one should be
discriminated against because of gender or any other reason. Title IX has
created opportunities for many women to compete in collegiate athletics.
However, the current interpretation of Title IX results more in the elimination
of opportunities than the creation of opportunities. The sports that are most
affected include many Olympic sports which are on the way to extinction at the
college level. The cuts in men's sports also hurt the women who compete in those
sports and who benefit from cross-training. We believe therefore that the gender
preferences and quotas must be abolished.
We hereby affix our names to this petition: